S o we had a lack luster series in England and got our butt kicked to wake us up. I think that kick came at the right time because it provides us time to think and plan for the future. That calls for some honest and brutal thinking on the part of BCCI and some actions that will help the game.
Let us start with the attitude first. I think, although everyone is vehemently denying it, the IPL has had a negative effect on the attitude of the youngsters. When you can get a big contract by bowling 4 good overs in a game or by scoring a quick 30-40-50 in a game, what is the motivation for the youngsters to graft an innings? Then you have the advertising contracts if you have reasonable success in IPL. With all this money being available quickly and by playing a few games, why should one toil over five days? So BCCI therefore needs to check the IPL program for its impact on the talent. They should look at diverting some money into a formal academy for a handful of individuals with sponsorships.
The same attitude is also reflected in the amount of preparation time and practice time that the players put in. Recently during the Fourth Test, the Indian bowling coach Eric Simmons was being interviewed on telly and he said that Praveen Kumar must be tired. Wasim Akram, who was in the commentary team, was fuming. He said that Praveen is just 23 and has just made his debut for India. He should be raring to go and not complaining of workload. He also mentioned that these days the bowlers bowl 3-4 overs at the nets and takes a break; there is never a long sustained spell. So the ability to work hard and give your 100 per cent is missing.
Third, the players need to be honest and transparent about their injuries. On this tour alone we have had numerous examples of players carrying injuries and hoping to recover in time. That is not a fair process because it robs an aspiring player of a berth on the touring team and secondly you are putting your own team at risk by playing with less than 100% fitness. The players should spend the right time on recovery and then get match ready.
Finally, the BCCI needs to take a longer term view. They need to identify the next generation of players and invest in their training, coaching and build a solid foundation for the future. We need to be in a position to defend the world cup and also dominate the game once we overcome this fall.
Tuesday, August 30, 2011
Friday, August 26, 2011
Fourth Test : The Oval – Abject Surrender!
India lost the fourth test match even before they walked on the field for the toss with their clueless team selection. First of all Praveen Kumar was declared injured not with his hand where he got hit while batting in the third test, but with his ankle! So the choice of the replacement was not Munaf Patel but R. P. Singh. Now RP himself was not expecting a recall in the test side and was on a holiday (apparently) in Miami. He is past his prime and definitely not match fit. The first over he bowled provided ample evidence of that. Then the team persisted with Raina, again an opportunity lost to try out Kohli. In the worst case he would have scored the same number of runs that Raina scored. Finally, there were also some doubts about Sehwag’s fitness. So it seems like either the team does not have faith in the players provided or they are selecting players very randomly without any logic.
Flintoff made a comment about the Indian team when he saw them at the nets before the start of the game. He observed that the team resembled a motley crew with various players wearing different outfits. Now that may seem like a trivial thing, but when you are playing as a team, you need to work as a team in every aspect. These small disciplinary things also show the team’s commitment and unity.
Strauss won the toss and decided to bat and from then on it was one way street. RP Singh very clearly demonstrated in his first over that he was rusty and short on match practice. That helped England to build a good opening partnership before the rains intervened on Day 1. I was in London on Day 1 and it looked pretty dull. At that stage it looked like the weather would play a big part in this test match and we may in fact manage a respectable draw. But that picture changed completely as India leaked runs by the bucket on Day 2 when Pietersen and Bell pulverized the attack. They continued on Day 3 and posted close to 600 runs with the goal of not having to bat the second time.
Indian response, on a pitch where they were expected to do well, was very predictable. Suddenly the ball was moving and jumping and darting. Gambhir not only dropped Pietersen when we were fielding but also had an injury to his head. That forced Rahul Dravid to open the innings yet again on this tour. Sehwag perished after scoring two boundaries, he was lucky to have survived the first ball. In no time Indians were reeling at 5-95. Ravi Sahstri had made an interesting observation about the England game plan. Their batters score heavily and spend a lot of time on the field, that leaves their bowlers with a lot of time to recuperate and attack with venom when they get the cherry in their hands. Dravid played a gem of an innings but he was the lone fighter, he carried his bat through and scored the third century on this tour. He got some support from Amit Mishra, who missed his well deserved 50 in the first innings and an almost century in the second innings. Gambhir came out to bat but he was searching for the ball. He looked out of sorts.
Following on after a collapse in the first innings, India started better in the second innings. Dravid opened yet again and was ruled out by the third umpire. Without any evidence from the hot spot, the umpire chose to overrule the decision of the field umpire. Tendulkar and Mishra, who came as night watchman, made batting look easy and at one stage a draw looked like a possible outcome. The second new ball saw both of them getting out without centuries and from then on we lost 7 wickets for 21 runs. In a way I was happy that Tendulkar did not get his ton of tons in this series, I want him to score that under happier circumstances and not after a 4-0 drubbing.
So a very well earned victory for the English team. They completely outplayed the Indian team which struggled with an injured squad and could never get accustomed to the conditions in England. This tour also exposed the weakness of the batters against moving, swinging and accurate bowling. The recovery from here is going to be a hard grind and some serious questions need to be answered. The BCCI needs to plan for the future and take some bold decisions to build a solid pipeline of talent for the future. It would be a pity if this is seen as just another series and no action is taken.
P.S.: On my way back from London, I bumped into Yuvraj Singh at Mumbai Immigration and spoke to him. We discussed his injury and also the series. He was very dejected to be back.
Flintoff made a comment about the Indian team when he saw them at the nets before the start of the game. He observed that the team resembled a motley crew with various players wearing different outfits. Now that may seem like a trivial thing, but when you are playing as a team, you need to work as a team in every aspect. These small disciplinary things also show the team’s commitment and unity.
Strauss won the toss and decided to bat and from then on it was one way street. RP Singh very clearly demonstrated in his first over that he was rusty and short on match practice. That helped England to build a good opening partnership before the rains intervened on Day 1. I was in London on Day 1 and it looked pretty dull. At that stage it looked like the weather would play a big part in this test match and we may in fact manage a respectable draw. But that picture changed completely as India leaked runs by the bucket on Day 2 when Pietersen and Bell pulverized the attack. They continued on Day 3 and posted close to 600 runs with the goal of not having to bat the second time.
Indian response, on a pitch where they were expected to do well, was very predictable. Suddenly the ball was moving and jumping and darting. Gambhir not only dropped Pietersen when we were fielding but also had an injury to his head. That forced Rahul Dravid to open the innings yet again on this tour. Sehwag perished after scoring two boundaries, he was lucky to have survived the first ball. In no time Indians were reeling at 5-95. Ravi Sahstri had made an interesting observation about the England game plan. Their batters score heavily and spend a lot of time on the field, that leaves their bowlers with a lot of time to recuperate and attack with venom when they get the cherry in their hands. Dravid played a gem of an innings but he was the lone fighter, he carried his bat through and scored the third century on this tour. He got some support from Amit Mishra, who missed his well deserved 50 in the first innings and an almost century in the second innings. Gambhir came out to bat but he was searching for the ball. He looked out of sorts.
Following on after a collapse in the first innings, India started better in the second innings. Dravid opened yet again and was ruled out by the third umpire. Without any evidence from the hot spot, the umpire chose to overrule the decision of the field umpire. Tendulkar and Mishra, who came as night watchman, made batting look easy and at one stage a draw looked like a possible outcome. The second new ball saw both of them getting out without centuries and from then on we lost 7 wickets for 21 runs. In a way I was happy that Tendulkar did not get his ton of tons in this series, I want him to score that under happier circumstances and not after a 4-0 drubbing.
So a very well earned victory for the English team. They completely outplayed the Indian team which struggled with an injured squad and could never get accustomed to the conditions in England. This tour also exposed the weakness of the batters against moving, swinging and accurate bowling. The recovery from here is going to be a hard grind and some serious questions need to be answered. The BCCI needs to plan for the future and take some bold decisions to build a solid pipeline of talent for the future. It would be a pity if this is seen as just another series and no action is taken.
P.S.: On my way back from London, I bumped into Yuvraj Singh at Mumbai Immigration and spoke to him. We discussed his injury and also the series. He was very dejected to be back.
Sunday, August 14, 2011
Third Test : Edgbaston – Humiliation Complete!
England deservedly won the series quite convincingly and dethroned India from the No. 1 spot in Test cricket rankings. I think everyone was kind of expecting this result but the manner in which the Indian team surrendered was beyond belief. There was no fight whatsoever to try to retain the ranking by squaring the series. The bowling was pedestrian, the batting was a joke and fielding was worse than a club side. When Sourav Ganguly said that he has not seen an Indian unit so bad in the past 10 years, I think everyone would agree with that assessment.
On a green top, the ball was expected to move a lot and statistically Strauss was due to win a toss. He immediately put the Indians in, and from then on it was a one way story. India had made a big deal of Sehweag’s return to the test side after an injury and he was being looked at as the Messiah who would pull this side out of their miseries. His contribution to the test match was exactly two deliveries; he got a Golden Duck pair. This Indian unit has not scored more than 300 runs on this tour and this test match was no exception. The batting of MSD was also more out of frustration than planned attack I thought. In the end with the bowling line up we have, a score of 224 was nothing.
England came out with a game plan and the firm of Strauss and Cook almost took them past the Indian total. Cook played a fabulous innings and showed how to build an innings as an opener. He fell 6 runs short of a well deserved triple hundred. Almost everyone scored freely and exposed the shallowness of the Indian bowling attack. We also dropped about half dozen catches, which did not help. At one stage, it looked like England could have gone and scored a thousand runs. Fortunately, Strauss declared at 710/7, as soon as Cook got out.
That left us to defend two days and a session to salvage a draw. A win was completely out of the equation. Sehwag perished on the 3rd ball of the innings and one must feel sorry for Rahul Dravid who has clearly stated his reluctance to open an innings but gets called out in the first over. Sehwag is a senior player and he cannot act as if he has no brains between his ears. The situation called for grafting an innings and not tonking the attack. The rest of the batting collapsed in a heap on the fourth day and only some lusty hitting in the end could ensure that we crossed 200. The lack of thinking was clearly visible when the Indians despite having the DRS in play, did not contest the appeal against Dravid; who looked like the only one who could rescue.
This team and the body language now shows signs that are not very encouraging for an Indian fan. The team hardly talks to each other on the field, there is no encouragement and above all everyone seems to be going through motions and hoping that this tour will get over. There are some serious questions being asked and the team is coming short on answers. The batting is good on dead wickets in the sub-continent. The new generation lacks the patience and the temperament to graft a test match innings. They are susceptible against moving and short-pitched bowling. We need to have players like Rohit Sharma, Pujara, Virat Kohli etc. play in the county circuit to gain some experience. The bowling lacks penetration. We need an attack that can take 20 wickets. Need a tear away fast bowler and a couple of quality spinners to achieve that. Bhajji and Zaheer are history. Mishra bowls more no balls than a fast bowler and leaks runs by the fifties. The captain needs to wake up and start driving these changes. It will be very sad if this defeat is considered as another day in the park and not given its rightful dues. First we need to arrest further sliding down the ladder and then start pushing up. It is a hard road ahead.
On a green top, the ball was expected to move a lot and statistically Strauss was due to win a toss. He immediately put the Indians in, and from then on it was a one way story. India had made a big deal of Sehweag’s return to the test side after an injury and he was being looked at as the Messiah who would pull this side out of their miseries. His contribution to the test match was exactly two deliveries; he got a Golden Duck pair. This Indian unit has not scored more than 300 runs on this tour and this test match was no exception. The batting of MSD was also more out of frustration than planned attack I thought. In the end with the bowling line up we have, a score of 224 was nothing.
England came out with a game plan and the firm of Strauss and Cook almost took them past the Indian total. Cook played a fabulous innings and showed how to build an innings as an opener. He fell 6 runs short of a well deserved triple hundred. Almost everyone scored freely and exposed the shallowness of the Indian bowling attack. We also dropped about half dozen catches, which did not help. At one stage, it looked like England could have gone and scored a thousand runs. Fortunately, Strauss declared at 710/7, as soon as Cook got out.
That left us to defend two days and a session to salvage a draw. A win was completely out of the equation. Sehwag perished on the 3rd ball of the innings and one must feel sorry for Rahul Dravid who has clearly stated his reluctance to open an innings but gets called out in the first over. Sehwag is a senior player and he cannot act as if he has no brains between his ears. The situation called for grafting an innings and not tonking the attack. The rest of the batting collapsed in a heap on the fourth day and only some lusty hitting in the end could ensure that we crossed 200. The lack of thinking was clearly visible when the Indians despite having the DRS in play, did not contest the appeal against Dravid; who looked like the only one who could rescue.
This team and the body language now shows signs that are not very encouraging for an Indian fan. The team hardly talks to each other on the field, there is no encouragement and above all everyone seems to be going through motions and hoping that this tour will get over. There are some serious questions being asked and the team is coming short on answers. The batting is good on dead wickets in the sub-continent. The new generation lacks the patience and the temperament to graft a test match innings. They are susceptible against moving and short-pitched bowling. We need to have players like Rohit Sharma, Pujara, Virat Kohli etc. play in the county circuit to gain some experience. The bowling lacks penetration. We need an attack that can take 20 wickets. Need a tear away fast bowler and a couple of quality spinners to achieve that. Bhajji and Zaheer are history. Mishra bowls more no balls than a fast bowler and leaks runs by the fifties. The captain needs to wake up and start driving these changes. It will be very sad if this defeat is considered as another day in the park and not given its rightful dues. First we need to arrest further sliding down the ladder and then start pushing up. It is a hard road ahead.
Monday, August 08, 2011
Whitewash is a definite possibility
A complete route of the world champion Indian team is a very likely outcome of the current series according to me. The squad is further depleted with the departure of Zaheer Khan and Yuvraj Singh. Sehwag is just back and will take some time to adjust and there is no second spinner who can make an impression here. So the chances of taking twenty English wickets are very remote. The batters, barring Dravid, have not shown any strength of character to bat out the English attack. SO it is all going to be downhill from here as far as I can see.
When I was a child and had just started following cricket, I always used to look at the most optimistic scenario and always believed that India would win the test. So after having heard the top order collapse, I would imagine the likes of Kirmani, Ghavri and Venkat to score runs by the bucket and get us to some respectable total. Then I would want our spinners to bowl out the opposition under 100 and get us a decent enough lead. So naïve. I guess that is an ability one loses as we mature and become more pragmatic. We need some folks from this Indian team believing in miracles and thinking like a kid to dream of winning from hopeless positions. Unless that happens, we are well and truly done in this series.
When I was a child and had just started following cricket, I always used to look at the most optimistic scenario and always believed that India would win the test. So after having heard the top order collapse, I would imagine the likes of Kirmani, Ghavri and Venkat to score runs by the bucket and get us to some respectable total. Then I would want our spinners to bowl out the opposition under 100 and get us a decent enough lead. So naïve. I guess that is an ability one loses as we mature and become more pragmatic. We need some folks from this Indian team believing in miracles and thinking like a kid to dream of winning from hopeless positions. Unless that happens, we are well and truly done in this series.
Tuesday, August 02, 2011
Second Test : Trent Bridge – Lost Opportunities
Indian team is not playing this series like champions and the Englishmen are hungry for success. You can draw that conclusion if you look at the progress of the second test match. A champion side is expected to make amends fast and bounce back with vengeance. I hate to say that the current team is not counting as a champion side on that criterion. I would have expected eleven fresh players ready to settle the score and win the second game convincingly. Instead what they showed was a total lack of penetration and the ability to force a quick end. It was a case of missed opportunities.
On the first day after having England on the mat at 8-124, we should have bowled them out under 175-200. Instead we let the tail wag and bring some respectability to the score. Then on Day 2, when Dravid yet again showed his class and ensured that the Indian response was good; we frittered away the solid start in the end. From 5-267, we collapsed in a heap for a paltry 288. There we lost an opportunity to build a lead of at least 150 plus to put some pressure.
Second innings was a completely different story. The bowling attack looked very pedestrian and with Harbhajan going out with injury (political injury ahead of being dropped I think), the work load on the three seamers was heavy. England plundered us to all parts of the ground and even Tim Bresnan looked like he will score a quick century. By the time Indians came off the field, I think they had lost the fight in their mind. And England were all charged up sighting a clean victory. The result was a predictable collapse worse than one had imagined. At one stage, the 42 all out looked under threat.
So even if we go on to win the next two matches on the trot and square the series, I think the damage is already done. I don’t think we can win even one game going forward. Because there are no reserves worth a mention and the team looks jaded. The captain too seems to have lost his magic touch and is looking bereft of ideas. His field placements, his bowling changes were pedestrian. MSD needs to wake up.
A lot of credit should also go to the English team and coach Flower. They prepare well and they play with intensity. That is why they have beaten the Australians regularly. They have a very good squad with a good reserves pool. Hence the worthy winners.
Here is my Report card for the Indian team:
On the first day after having England on the mat at 8-124, we should have bowled them out under 175-200. Instead we let the tail wag and bring some respectability to the score. Then on Day 2, when Dravid yet again showed his class and ensured that the Indian response was good; we frittered away the solid start in the end. From 5-267, we collapsed in a heap for a paltry 288. There we lost an opportunity to build a lead of at least 150 plus to put some pressure.
Second innings was a completely different story. The bowling attack looked very pedestrian and with Harbhajan going out with injury (political injury ahead of being dropped I think), the work load on the three seamers was heavy. England plundered us to all parts of the ground and even Tim Bresnan looked like he will score a quick century. By the time Indians came off the field, I think they had lost the fight in their mind. And England were all charged up sighting a clean victory. The result was a predictable collapse worse than one had imagined. At one stage, the 42 all out looked under threat.
So even if we go on to win the next two matches on the trot and square the series, I think the damage is already done. I don’t think we can win even one game going forward. Because there are no reserves worth a mention and the team looks jaded. The captain too seems to have lost his magic touch and is looking bereft of ideas. His field placements, his bowling changes were pedestrian. MSD needs to wake up.
A lot of credit should also go to the English team and coach Flower. They prepare well and they play with intensity. That is why they have beaten the Australians regularly. They have a very good squad with a good reserves pool. Hence the worthy winners.
Here is my Report card for the Indian team:
- Abhinav Mukund : 3/10 Not a test class opener.
- Rahul Dravid: 8/10 The lone star.
- VVS Laxman: 5/10 Technique and poetry still good.
- Sachin Tendulkar: 3/10 Looks a pale shadow of himself.
- Suresh Raina: 2/10 Short pitched balls.
- Yuvraj Singh: 5/10 Only one game so far.
- MS Dhoni: 1/10 Poor captaincy, poorer batting.
- Harbhajan Singh: 1/10 Is he a bowler? Should have been dropped long back.
- Praveen Kumar: 5/10 Workhorse, bowled his heart out.
- Ishant Sharma: 4/10 Good in short spells.
- Sreesanth: 4/10 Which one woke up today?
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)